Knovolo Mobile Marketing Reviews

Smithsonian Channel Mobile Marketing for Aerial America

August 22, 2011
Leave a Comment

I came across a fantastic mobile engagement on the back of this year’s Smithsonian Folklife Festival brochure. These guys really put a lot of thought into this mobile promotion, and for the most part, it created an excellent mobile user experience in a time when many marketers are throwing together poor mobile campaigns.

More Ways Than One

Mobile Marketing Campaign for Aerial America

Mobile Marketing Campaign for Aerial America

Many mobile campaigns these days only offer one door for mobile users to walk through: a QR code, a SMS call-to-action, or maybe a link. A solid mobile campaign will offer several different doors to accommodate the myriad of devices and user preferences out there, and this Smithsonian Channel ad does just that. They offer a QR code, a SMS call-to-action (text AERIAL to 74699), and they spell out the link that the QR code and SMS point to: http:smithchan.com/aerial.

This approach is critical for including the highest possible number of mobile users. Although QR codes have been out for a while, the majority of people in America don’t know exactly what QR codes are for, so relying on that as the only way for consumers to interact with you on their mobile devices is like trying to sell a book written in Greek to New Yorkers on their lunch break.

SMS (text messaging) is a widely supported technology among mobile phones (essentially supported by all mobile devices), but some users are cautious of getting extra charges, using up their allotted texts, or getting spammed in the future and may not want to text in. Also, SMS great for having users sign up to receive periodic text updates or coupons from you, but again, if you rely on it as the sole means of interaction with mobile users, you will be leaving some people out.

This is why it’s important to offer the URL itself, in print, in addition to other mobile entry methods discussed above. People who aren’t comfortable with other methods can always access your mobile content the “hard way” by typing in the web address themselves, and Smithsonian Channel even makes this easier with a shortened URL (although this could be a lot shorter). However, for mobile users who are accustomed to scanning QR codes and texting to short codes, entering a URL is almost as bad as having to write down the website on a napkin so that they can visit later when they’re in front of a computer.

In addition to all of these mobile calls-to-action, there’s a traditional website link (www.smithsonianchannel.com) printed near the bottom of the ad. The mobile engagements are important for catching people right when they see the ad, before they forget and move on with their lives. If, however, for those that take the ad all the way back to their computer (like I did), it’s quite insightful to have a small line telling us how to get there without using a cell phone. This makes it easy to watch the videos comfortably on our larger computer screens.

Mobile Web
The mobile website that the QR code, text messaging, and URL take you to (http:smithchan.com/aerial) is quite well done and looks great on all the smartphones we tested it on. The page is very nicely formatted, and the 45-minute episodes streamed quite well, with few breaks or interruptions. We saw some HTML5 in the source code, and like how the page fills all of the mobile screen, no matter its size. (It doesn’t look very good on computers, but it’s not supposed to!)

Mobile Webpage not looking very good on older phone

The Mobile Website doesn't look very good on this older smartphone, the HTC Excalibur.

The only disappointment we encountered was viewing the website on non-smartphones. There was no simpler code served to basic feature phones and the like, which means that those types of devices try valiantly to load the whole page, but ultimately fail in rendering anything usable. This page uses some JavaScript and advanced CSS that feature phones, older smartphones, and most Blackberries should not be expected to render at all, so there should a much lighter version of the mobile web page for these older/more basic devices. They ought to be able to read about Aerial America and learn about where they can watch the free episodes. There could, for example, be a form where the users enters their email address to receive links to the episodes so that they can watch later from their computers.

Here at Knovolo, we have been developing our own “advanced device detection” technology to address this problem. In fact, as of last month only 35% of American adults own smartphones. Mobile marketing campaigns that don’t address non-smartphone mobile users are leaving out a lot of people.

Summary
Aside from isolating non-smartphone users, this mobile marketing campaign for Smithsonian Channel’s new Aerial America was excellent. We hope that others marketers that are venturing into mobile will have mobile websites and call-to-actions of similar quality.


Taco Bell Thinks ‘Outside the Bun’ with its Mobile Experience

July 12, 2011
Leave a Comment

While enjoying a couple of supreme tacos today at Taco Bell, I was delighted to find two supreme mobile call-to-actions:

1 | The first was a flyer advertising jobs at Taco Bell. It had a QR code which, once I scanned it, took me to a page about jobs and careers at TBell. This page looked pretty good on my MyTouch, and featured a video which played nicely.
The job search feature worked quite well, and it was very good that they added a link to the full site in case you somehow ind yourself in the mobile version on your computer.

They also provided a web address to enter – this is crucial because many mobile users aren’t familiar with QR codes yet. It was confusing, however, that the web address they spelled out, www.tacobell.com/careers, isn’t the same one that the QR code points to. In fact, once you land on www.tacobell.com/careers with your mobile, you get directed to m.tacobell.com, their mobile homepage, and since there’s no link about careers, it’s a dead-end. This means that non-QR code users can NOT actually get to the career content, which isn’t happy.

image

2 | Next, I spotted an SMS (text message) call-to-action on my cup. This user experience wasn’t quite as seamless as the last recruitment flyer, but was functional nevertheless. The code was long and tedious to enter on a mobile phone and the text message responses were very technically worded and lacked the pzazz of the wording on the cup, but overall it functioned just fine. Perhaps I’d have been happier if I’d actually won something.

image

Room for Improvement

The mobile landing page was a little too wide for my screen and created the need to scroll sideways just to see the whole thing.

There was no other way than scanning the short code to get to career link on a mobile.

To do a job search, I had to enter my city or zip code. Why not also have the option of using my GPS to determine my location? It’s a fair bet that if I’m looking at the flyer, I’m probably standing in the part of the world where I’m interested in working.

Takeaway

Overall, I was quite impressed with Taco Bell’s mobile efforts: they appear to be at the forefront of eateries as far as mobile marketing & mobile engagement is concerned. There are certainly a few things they could improve upon, but the webpages were mobile-optimized, and everything worked, which is more than you get with many of today’s mobile efforts.

I’m looking forward to seeing how Taco Bell will continue to think outside the bun.


Calvin Klein: Knovolo Mobile Marketing Review

November 6, 2010
Leave a Comment

 

Introduction

Calvin Klein's QR Code

Calvin Klein's QR Code

Calvin Klein implemented a mobile campaign this summer with QR codes on billboards in New York and Los Angeles.
Read more

 

 


The Basics

Company Calvin Klein
Date Summer 2010
Description This campaign used large QR codes to promote Calvin Klein jeans.
Mobile Services Provider Ace Group
Location(s) NY City, LA
Mobile Technologies Used QR Code, Mobile Web, Mobile Video
Company Response “It was very successful and you will see QR codes continue to be integrated into our upcoming campaigns,” said Jennifer Crawford, vice president of corporate communications at Calvin Klein, New York.”
Jennifer Crawford: VP of corporate communications at Calvin Klein
More Information: Mobile Marketer

 


Mobile Technology Rating

QR Code

5-star Knovolo Mobile Rating

The QR codes points to a mobile-optimized site, which worked well on all of our testing devices. At this point, many marketers are smart to use QR codes, but they often direct mobile users to websites that aren’t mobile-optimized.
On a side note, while the use of QR codes continues to grow, many mobile phone users (perhaps around 60% in America) don’t have phones capable of running the proper software, and they simply can’t interact with this ad. To be the most inclusive, there should also be an SMS call-to-action.
Mobile Web

4-star Knovolo Mobile Rating

Although the mobile website is optimized for mobile, the content is lacking. There are simply two social icons and a video. It’d be nice to see some pictures of models wearing jeans (perhaps screenshots from video), and information about nearby Calvin Klein stores. However, the domain, ckj.mobi, is great the mobile.
Mobile Video

3-star Knovolo Mobile Rating

This video played on most smartphones that we tested, but not on my T-Mobile MyTouch (Android 2.0). On other devices, it usually took a long time to load, and stopped often for buffering. There was no pause button, so you couldn’t stop it from playing and actually let it buffer.
Social Networks

3-star Knovolo Mobile Rating

The inclusion of social network icons (Facebook and Twitter) is 100% amazing and definitely the way to go. However, these two icons don’t point to their respective CKJ social profiles, but rather they act as a “Like This” button and point to a page that prompts you to share the link. To share the link on either network, you have to already be logged in from your phone, and if you’re not logged in (or if you don’t have an account – gasp!) you can’t see anything. I’d rather click on the F icon and be taken to the Facebook profile (same thing for Twitter) whether or not I’m logged in.
Device Detection

1-star Knovolo Mobile Rating

If you hit ckj.mobi from a computer, the Calvin Klein should recognize that you’re not on a mobile device and send you to the desktop website www.calvinklein.com. Similarly, if a mobile user ends up on www.calvinklein.com, that site should automatically redirect to the mobile site, which it doesn’t.
mCommerce

1-star Knovolo Mobile Rating

There is a lot of opportunity here for CKJ to have used Mobile Commerce. From the mobile website, one should be able to – at the very minimum – locate the nearest CK store based on GPS or zip code. It also should be assumed that consumers might be interested in browsing through a mobile store after watching the video. As a bonus, the mobile user should be able to buy and order from the comfort of their mobile phone, just like they can do from a computer.

 


Final Rating

3-star Knovolo Mobile Rating

Although Calvin Klein and Ace Group did a great job with the QR Code and mobile-optimized website, the mobile video and social network buttons were troublesome, while mCommerce and device detection weren’t present at all. This mobile campaign was a start in the right direction, but is still lacking.


    Enter your email address to subscribe to this blog and receive notifications of new posts by email.

    Join 433 other followers